How Do You Know When to Use the Limit Comparison Test

Learning Objectives

  • 5.four.1 Use the comparing test to test a series for convergence.
  • 5.4.2 Use the limit comparison test to determine convergence of a series.

We have seen that the integral test allows us to decide the convergence or divergence of a serial by comparison information technology to a related improper integral. In this department, we show how to employ comparing tests to make up one's mind the convergence or divergence of a series by comparing it to a series whose convergence or difference is known. Typically these tests are used to make up one's mind convergence of series that are like to geometric series or p-series.

Comparison Exam

In the preceding two sections, we discussed two large classes of serial: geometric series and p-series. Nosotros know exactly when these series converge and when they diverge. Hither nosotros prove how to use the convergence or divergence of these series to testify convergence or divergence for other serial, using a method called the comparison test.

For example, consider the series

n = ane 1 due north 2 + 1 . n = i 1 n 2 + 1 .

This series looks similar to the convergent serial

north = one i n 2 . n = ane 1 n 2 .

Since the terms in each of the serial are positive, the sequence of partial sums for each serial is monotone increasing. Furthermore, since

0 < 1 n 2 + 1 < ane n 2 0 < 1 n ii + one < 1 n two

for all positive integers due north , n , the k th thousand thursday partial sum S k South k of northward = 1 1 n 2 + ane n = 1 1 n 2 + 1 satisfies

S g = n = one k 1 n ii + i < north = 1 thousand one n 2 < n = 1 1 n 2 . S k = northward = one k i north 2 + one < north = 1 1000 i n 2 < n = 1 i n ii .

(See Effigy five.16(a) and Table v.ane.) Since the series on the correct converges, the sequence { South g } { Southward k } is bounded to a higher place. We conclude that { Due south 1000 } { S k } is a monotone increasing sequence that is bounded to a higher place. Therefore, by the Monotone Convergence Theorem, { S k } { S m } converges, and thus

due north = 1 1 n 2 + one n = 1 1 due north 2 + one

converges.

Similarly, consider the series

n = 1 1 n 1 / two . north = ane 1 n one / ii .

This series looks similar to the divergent series

n = 1 ane n . n = 1 1 n .

The sequence of partial sums for each series is monotone increasing and

1 n 1 / 2 > one n > 0 i n i / 2 > 1 n > 0

for every positive integer northward . n . Therefore, the k th k thursday partial sum Southward grand S k of north = 1 1 n ane / 2 northward = ane 1 n 1 / 2 satisfies

South thousand = north = 1 thou 1 n 1 / ii > n = one k 1 n . S k = north = 1 k 1 n ane / 2 > north = 1 k 1 n .

(See Figure 5.xvi(b) and Tabular array 5.2.) Since the serial north = 1 1 / n northward = ane 1 / due north diverges to infinity, the sequence of partial sums due north = 1 k 1 / n n = 1 1000 i / n is unbounded. Consequently, { S k } { Southward k } is an unbounded sequence, and therefore diverges. We conclude that

n = ane 1 n i / 2 n = i 1 n 1 / 2

diverges.

This shows two graphs side by side. The first shows plotted points for the partial sums for the sum of 1/n^2 and the sum 1/(n^2 + 1). Each of the partial sums for the latter is less than the corresponding partial sum for the former. The second shows plotted points for the partial sums for the sum of 1/(n - 0.5) and the sum 1/n. Each of the partial sums for the latter is less than the corresponding partial sum for the former.

Figure v.sixteen (a) Each of the partial sums for the given series is less than the corresponding fractional sum for the converging p series . p series . (b) Each of the partial sums for the given serial is greater than the corresponding partial sum for the diverging harmonic serial.

k k 1 ane 2 two three 3 4 iv five five vi six 7 7 viii 8
n = 1 k 1 northward 2 + ane n = one k 1 north 2 + 1 0.5 0.5 0.7 0.7 0.viii 0.eight 0.8588 0.8588 0.8973 0.8973 0.9243 0.9243 0.9443 0.9443 0.9597 0.9597
northward = 1 k one n 2 northward = 1 thou 1 due north two 1 1 ane.25 one.25 ane.3611 1.3611 1.4236 ane.4236 1.4636 one.4636 one.4914 i.4914 1.5118 1.5118 1.5274 1.5274

Table 5.ane Comparing a serial with a p-series (p = two)

one thousand m i 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 5 6 6 7 7 eight 8
n = one one thousand ane due north 1 / 2 northward = 1 k one due north 1 / 2 two ii ii.6667 two.6667 3.0667 3.0667 iii.3524 3.3524 three.5746 3.5746 3.7564 3.7564 iii.9103 3.9103 4.0436 4.0436
n = ane k ane n northward = i k 1 n 1 one 1.5 one.v 1.8333 ane.8333 2.0933 2.0933 2.2833 2.2833 2.45 2.45 2.5929 2.5929 2.7179 2.7179

Table v.2 Comparing a series with the harmonic series

Theorem 5.11

Comparison Test

  1. Suppose there exists an integer N N such that 0 a north b north 0 a n b n for all n N . n N . If n = 1 b n northward = 1 b north converges, then north = 1 a north n = 1 a n converges.
  2. Suppose there exists an integer Northward Due north such that a n b n 0 a n b northward 0 for all northward Northward . n N . If due north = 1 b northward n = i b n diverges, then n = 1 a n n = ane a northward diverges.

Proof

We show office i. The proof of office ii. is the contrapositive of role i. Let { S one thousand } { S k } be the sequence of partial sums associated with due north = ane a due north , north = one a n , and permit L = n = 1 b n . L = n = 1 b n . Since the terms a n 0 , a n 0 ,

S thousand = a one + a ii + + a 1000 a i + a two + + a g + a thousand + 1 = South k + 1 . S thousand = a 1 + a 2 + + a chiliad a one + a 2 + + a yard + a k + 1 = S m + 1 .

Therefore, the sequence of fractional sums is increasing. Farther, since a north b n a n b n for all n N , n North , then

n = N k a due north n = Due north k b n n = ane b n = L . n = N k a n n = Due north k b north n = ane b n = L .

Therefore, for all k ane , one thousand ane ,

S k = ( a 1 + a 2 + + a N 1 ) + n = N one thousand a n ( a ane + a 2 + + a North one ) + 50 . S 1000 = ( a 1 + a 2 + + a Northward 1 ) + n = N one thousand a due north ( a 1 + a 2 + + a North 1 ) + L .

Since a i + a two + + a N 1 a ane + a two + + a Due north 1 is a finite number, we conclude that the sequence { South 1000 } { S g } is bounded above. Therefore, { S m } { South k } is an increasing sequence that is bounded higher up. Past the Monotone Convergence Theorem, nosotros conclude that { Due south g } { S m } converges, and therefore the serial due north = 1 a n north = one a n converges.

To use the comparison test to determine the convergence or divergence of a series n = 1 a n , n = one a n , information technology is necessary to find a suitable series with which to compare information technology. Since we know the convergence properties of geometric serial and p-serial, these series are often used. If in that location exists an integer North N such that for all n Northward , n N , each term a northward a due north is less than each corresponding term of a known convergent serial, then n = 1 a due north northward = 1 a n converges. Similarly, if there exists an integer North N such that for all n N , n N , each term a due north a n is greater than each corresponding term of a known divergent series, then n = ane a northward n = 1 a due north diverges.

Example 5.17

Using the Comparison Exam

For each of the following series, use the comparison examination to make up one's mind whether the series converges or diverges.

  1. n = ane one n 3 + 3 n + i n = ane 1 n iii + 3 n + one
  2. n = 1 1 2 n + one due north = 1 1 2 due north + 1
  3. due north = 2 1 ln ( n ) northward = 2 one ln ( due north )

Checkpoint 5.16

Employ the comparing exam to make up one's mind if the series n = 1 n n three + due north + 1 n = ane n north three + n + 1 converges or diverges.

Limit Comparison Test

The comparison test works nicely if we can find a comparable series satisfying the hypothesis of the test. Notwithstanding, sometimes finding an appropriate series can be difficult. Consider the series

n = ii 1 northward 2 ane . n = ii 1 northward 2 1 .

It is natural to compare this series with the convergent series

northward = 2 1 north 2 . due north = 2 1 northward 2 .

However, this serial does not satisfy the hypothesis necessary to use the comparison test because

i due north ii 1 > 1 n ii one n 2 1 > ane n 2

for all integers n 2 . n ii . Although we could wait for a different series with which to compare n = 2 1 / ( n ii ane ) , north = two 1 / ( n 2 1 ) , instead we show how nosotros can use the limit comparing test to compare

n = 2 1 north 2 1 and n = 2 i due north ii . n = ii 1 n 2 1 and n = 2 1 n two .

Let usa examine the idea backside the limit comparison examination. Consider 2 serial northward = ane a n due north = ane a due north and northward = 1 b n . n = i b n . with positive terms a n and b northward a due north and b north and evaluate

lim due north a n b n . lim n a northward b north .

If

lim n a n b due north = L 0 , lim northward a due north b n = L 0 ,

then, for northward northward sufficiently large, a north Fifty b n . a due north L b due north . Therefore, either both series converge or both series diverge. For the series due north = two one / ( n ii 1 ) n = 2 1 / ( due north 2 1 ) and n = 2 1 / north two , n = two ane / north 2 , we see that

lim n 1 / ( n ii 1 ) ane / n 2 = lim n n ii north 2 i = one . lim northward 1 / ( due north ii 1 ) 1 / due north 2 = lim n north ii n 2 1 = 1 .

Since n = 2 1 / n 2 n = ii 1 / n 2 converges, we conclude that

n = 2 1 north two ane north = two 1 north ii 1

converges.

The limit comparison test tin can exist used in 2 other cases. Suppose

lim n a n b n = 0 . lim n a n b n = 0 .

In this case, { a northward / b due north } { a northward / b n } is a bounded sequence. As a outcome, at that place exists a constant M M such that a n G b north . a due north K b n . Therefore, if n = i b due north n = 1 b n converges, then n = 1 a n northward = i a northward converges. On the other hand, suppose

lim northward a n b n = . lim n a n b northward = .

In this case, { a due north / b north } { a n / b n } is an unbounded sequence. Therefore, for every constant M M there exists an integer N North such that a n Thousand b due north a n M b n for all n N . northward N . Therefore, if north = one b n north = 1 b n diverges, then northward = 1 a north n = 1 a n diverges as well.

Theorem 5.12

Limit Comparison Test

Allow a n , b northward 0 a northward , b due north 0 for all n 1 . due north 1 .

  1. If lim due north a north / b n = 50 0 , lim northward a due north / b due north = 50 0 , then north = ane a n due north = i a n and n = one b n north = one b n both converge or both diverge.
  2. If lim north a n / b n = 0 lim due north a n / b north = 0 and n = one b northward northward = 1 b n converges, then north = 1 a north north = 1 a n converges.
  3. If lim due north a n / b north = lim due north a north / b n = and north = 1 b n due north = 1 b n diverges, so due north = 1 a north due north = 1 a n diverges.

Note that if a north / b n 0 a north / b n 0 and northward = ane b n due north = i b n diverges, the limit comparison test gives no data. Similarly, if a n / b northward a northward / b n and n = 1 b n n = i b n converges, the exam besides provides no information. For example, consider the two series n = 1 one / n due north = 1 1 / n and n = 1 i / n 2 . n = one ane / n 2 . These serial are both p-serial with p = ane / 2 p = 1 / 2 and p = 2 , p = two , respectively. Since p = ane / 2 < ane , p = ane / 2 < 1 , the series n = 1 one / due north northward = one 1 / n diverges. On the other paw, since p = ii > 1 , p = 2 > 1 , the series northward = 1 i / north ii n = 1 ane / n ii converges. However, suppose we attempted to apply the limit comparison examination, using the convergent p series p series n = 1 1 / n 3 n = one ane / n 3 as our comparison series. Outset, we run into that

1 / north 1 / n 3 = northward iii n = n 5 / 2 as n . 1 / n 1 / due north 3 = n three n = n v / ii as north .

Similarly, we see that

i / north 2 1 / n 3 = n as n . 1 / due north 2 ane / n three = northward as n .

Therefore, if a n / b n a due north / b n when n = 1 b n n = 1 b n converges, nosotros do not gain whatever information on the convergence or divergence of n = 1 a n . n = 1 a n .

Example v.eighteen

Using the Limit Comparison Test

For each of the post-obit series, use the limit comparison test to make up one's mind whether the series converges or diverges. If the test does not utilize, say so.

  1. n = 1 i northward + 1 n = 1 one n + i
  2. n = 1 ii n + 1 3 north due north = i 2 n + i three n
  3. n = ane ln ( n ) north ii due north = ane ln ( n ) n 2

Checkpoint 5.17

Use the limit comparing test to determine whether the series north = 1 5 northward 3 north + ii n = 1 v northward 3 n + 2 converges or diverges.

Section 5.4 Exercises

Apply the comparison test to determine whether the following serial converge.

194 .

northward = 1 a n n = 1 a n where a n = 2 n ( northward + 1 ) a n = two n ( n + one )

195 .

n = 1 a n due north = 1 a n where a n = 1 n ( n + 1 / two ) a n = 1 due north ( n + 1 / ii )

196 .

n = one ane 2 ( n + one ) n = 1 ane ii ( n + 1 )

197 .

n = ane 1 2 northward 1 n = 1 ane 2 due north 1

198 .

n = 2 1 ( n ln n ) 2 n = 2 i ( n ln due north ) 2

199 .

n = one n ! ( n + 2 ) ! n = 1 northward ! ( n + 2 ) !

200 .

n = one ane due north ! n = i 1 due north !

201 .

northward = 1 sin ( 1 / north ) northward n = one sin ( ane / n ) n

202 .

north = 1 sin ii n north ii n = one sin 2 north n two

203 .

due north = ane sin ( 1 / n ) n n = ane sin ( 1 / northward ) n

204 .

northward = ane n 1.2 1 n 2.three + 1 northward = 1 due north one.ii one northward ii.3 + i

205 .

n = 1 northward + 1 north n due north = 1 n + i n n

206 .

due north = 1 n 4 n 4 + n ii iii n = 1 n 4 n 4 + n 2 iii

Utilise the limit comparison examination to determine whether each of the following series converges or diverges.

207 .

due north = one ( ln n north ) ii n = i ( ln n northward ) 2

208 .

n = 1 ( ln n n 0.6 ) 2 n = 1 ( ln n n 0.half dozen ) 2

209 .

n = 1 ln ( 1 + 1 northward ) n n = 1 ln ( 1 + 1 n ) n

210 .

n = 1 ln ( ane + 1 n two ) northward = 1 ln ( 1 + 1 northward 2 )

211 .

n = 1 1 4 north 3 due north n = ane i four n three n

212 .

n = 1 ane n 2 north sin n n = 1 ane n 2 n sin n

213 .

north = 1 1 e ( i.1 ) n 3 n n = 1 1 e ( i.one ) n iii n

214 .

northward = 1 1 e ( 1.01 ) n 3 n n = ane ane e ( 1.01 ) northward iii n

215 .

n = 1 1 due north 1 + 1 / northward n = 1 1 n 1 + 1 / n

216 .

due north = 1 i ii 1 + 1 / north north 1 + 1 / north n = 1 1 2 ane + 1 / due north n 1 + 1 / n

217 .

n = 1 ( 1 n sin ( 1 due north ) ) n = ane ( 1 n sin ( 1 due north ) )

218 .

n = 1 ( i cos ( 1 n ) ) northward = 1 ( 1 cos ( one n ) )

219 .

n = 1 1 north ( Ï€ 2 tan −ane north ) due north = 1 one north ( Ï€ 2 tan −1 n )

220 .

n = ane ( ane i n ) north . n n = i ( 1 ane n ) n . due north (Hint: ( 1 1 n ) due north i / e . ) ( 1 1 n ) due north 1 / e . )

221 .

north = i ( 1 e −i / n ) n = 1 ( 1 eastward −one / n ) (Hint: 1 / e ( 1 1 / due north ) n , one / e ( 1 1 / n ) n , and then 1 e −1 / n 1 / n . ) i e −1 / n 1 / n . )

222 .

Does n = two ane ( ln n ) p north = 2 1 ( ln n ) p converge if p p is large plenty? If so, for which p ? p ?

223 .

Does north = 1 ( ( ln north ) northward ) p n = 1 ( ( ln n ) due north ) p converge if p p is large enough? If so, for which p ? p ?

224 .

For which p p does the serial northward = 1 ii p north / 3 due north n = i 2 p n / three northward converge?

225 .

For which p > 0 p > 0 does the series n = 1 due north p 2 n n = 1 n p ii n converge?

226 .

For which r > 0 r > 0 does the series n = 1 r n two ii n n = 1 r n ii 2 n converge?

227 .

For which r > 0 r > 0 does the serial n = 1 2 n r n 2 n = 1 two northward r n 2 converge?

228 .

Find all values of p p and q q such that due north = i n p ( northward ! ) q north = one n p ( northward ! ) q converges.

229 .

Does n = i sin 2 ( n r / 2 ) n n = ane sin 2 ( n r / 2 ) due north converge or diverge? Explain.

230 .

Explain why, for each n , n , at least one of { | sin northward | , | sin ( northward + 1 ) | ,... , | sin n + 6 | } { | sin northward | , | sin ( north + 1 ) | ,... , | sin n + 6 | } is larger than one / two . i / 2 . Use this relation to test convergence of northward = 1 | sin northward | n . northward = 1 | sin n | n .

231 .

Suppose that a due north 0 a n 0 and b n 0 b due north 0 and that north = 1 a 2 n due north = 1 a ii n and n = 1 b 2 n n = 1 b 2 n converge. Evidence that n = 1 a northward b n n = i a n b n converges and due north = 1 a due north b n i 2 ( n = 1 a northward 2 + n = 1 b n ii ) . due north = 1 a north b n 1 2 ( northward = 1 a n two + n = 1 b north ii ) .

232 .

Does northward = one 2 ln ln n northward = one ii ln ln n converge? (Hint: Write 2 ln ln n ii ln ln n equally a power of ln north . ) ln north . )

233 .

Does n = one ( ln n ) ln n n = ane ( ln n ) ln n converge? (Hint: Use north = e ln ( n ) n = east ln ( northward ) to compare to a p serial . ) p series . )

234 .

Does due north = two ( ln n ) ln ln n due north = two ( ln n ) ln ln north converge? (Hint: Compare a due north a northward to 1 / n . ) 1 / n . )

235 .

Testify that if a n 0 a n 0 and n = 1 a n n = 1 a n converges, and then due north = 1 a two northward n = 1 a ii due north converges. If n = 1 a 2 n due north = 1 a ii northward converges, does due north = i a n n = 1 a north necessarily converge?

236 .

Suppose that a n > 0 a n > 0 for all n n and that north = 1 a northward north = 1 a northward converges. Suppose that b due north b n is an arbitrary sequence of zeros and ones. Does n = 1 a n b north n = 1 a due north b n necessarily converge?

237 .

Suppose that a north > 0 a north > 0 for all n due north and that n = 1 a n n = 1 a n diverges. Suppose that b n b n is an arbitrary sequence of zeros and ones with infinitely many terms equal to 1. Does due north = 1 a n b north n = 1 a n b n necessarily diverge?

238 .

Complete the details of the post-obit argument: If northward = one 1 n n = 1 1 due north converges to a finite sum s , southward , then 1 two due south = i 2 + 1 4 + ane vi + i 2 southward = one 2 + 1 4 + 1 half dozen + and s 1 ii due south = one + 1 iii + ane five + . due south 1 2 s = i + 1 iii + one 5 + . Why does this lead to a contradiction?

239 .

Show that if a n 0 a north 0 and north = ane a 2 northward n = 1 a 2 n converges, then n = 1 sin 2 ( a n ) n = one sin 2 ( a n ) converges.

240 .

Suppose that a n / b north 0 a due north / b north 0 in the comparison test, where a n 0 a n 0 and b n 0. b n 0. Prove that if b n b n converges, then a due north a northward converges.

241 .

Allow b n b n be an infinite sequence of zeros and ones. What is the largest possible value of ten = n = i b north / 2 due north ? ten = north = 1 b north / two n ?

242 .

Let d n d northward be an space sequence of digits, significant d n d northward takes values in { 0 , one ,… , 9 } . { 0 , 1 ,… , 9 } . What is the largest possible value of 10 = n = 1 d due north / ten n x = north = 1 d n / 10 northward that converges?

243 .

Explicate why, if x > 1 / ii , x > 1 / 2 , so x ten cannot be written x = due north = 2 b n 2 north ( b due north = 0 or 1 , b 1 = 0 ) . x = north = 2 b due north 2 n ( b n = 0 or one , b 1 = 0 ) .

244 .

[T] Evelyn has a perfect balancing scale, an unlimited number of 1 -kg ane -kg weights, and i each of 1 / 2 -kg , one / four -kg , one / 8 -kg , 1 / 2 -kg , i / 4 -kg , i / 8 -kg , and and so on weights. She wishes to counterbalance a meteorite of unspecified origin to capricious precision. Assuming the scale is big plenty, can she do information technology? What does this have to practice with infinite series?

245 .

[T] Robert wants to know his body mass to arbitrary precision. He has a big balancing scale that works perfectly, an unlimited drove of 1 -kg ane -kg weights, and 9 each of 0.ane -kg, 0.1 -kg, 0.01 -kg , 0.001 -kg, 0.01 -kg , 0.001 -kg, and and then on weights. Bold the scale is large enough, can he practice this? What does this have to practise with infinite series?

246 .

The series n = 1 ane ii n n = i 1 ii north is half the harmonic serial and hence diverges. Information technology is obtained from the harmonic series by deleting all terms in which n n is odd. Let m > 1 m > 1 be fixed. Show, more by and large, that deleting all terms 1 / due north 1 / n where n = m k n = 1000 k for some integer k 1000 also results in a divergent series.

247 .

In view of the previous practise, it may be surprising that a subseries of the harmonic series in which about ane in every five terms is deleted might converge. A depleted harmonic serial is a serial obtained from n = one 1 n north = 1 1 n by removing any term 1 / n 1 / n if a given digit, say 9 , 9 , appears in the decimal expansion of n . n . Argue that this depleted harmonic series converges by answering the post-obit questions.

  1. How many whole numbers northward n take d d digits?
  2. How many d -digit d -digit whole numbers h ( d ) . h ( d ) . practice not incorporate 9 9 as one or more than of their digits?
  3. What is the smallest d -digit d -digit number m ( d ) ? m ( d ) ?
  4. Explain why the deleted harmonic series is divisional past d = one h ( d ) grand ( d ) . d = 1 h ( d ) m ( d ) .
  5. Show that d = i h ( d ) grand ( d ) d = 1 h ( d ) m ( d ) converges.

248 .

Suppose that a sequence of numbers a n > 0 a n > 0 has the property that a 1 = 1 a ane = i and a n + 1 = one n + 1 S n , a due north + 1 = 1 n + ane S n , where Southward n = a one + + a n . S n = a 1 + + a n . Tin can you determine whether n = 1 a n n = 1 a n converges? (Hint: Southward n S n is monotone.)

249 .

Suppose that a sequence of numbers a n > 0 a north > 0 has the belongings that a 1 = one a 1 = 1 and a north + one = 1 ( north + 1 ) 2 Southward n , a n + ane = 1 ( n + i ) two S northward , where S n = a ane + + a north . S n = a 1 + + a n . Can yous determine whether n = 1 a n northward = ane a northward converges? (Hint: S 2 = a 2 + a 1 = a 2 + South one = a two + 1 = 1 + 1 / 4 = ( 1 + 1 / 4 ) S 1 , S 2 = a 2 + a i = a two + Southward 1 = a 2 + 1 = ane + one / four = ( 1 + one / 4 ) S 1 , S 3 = one 3 2 South two + S 2 = ( 1 + one / 9 ) Due south ii = ( ane + ane / ix ) ( 1 + 1 / 4 ) Southward 1 , S 3 = 1 3 2 S ii + Southward two = ( 1 + 1 / 9 ) Due south 2 = ( one + 1 / 9 ) ( 1 + 1 / 4 ) Due south ane , etc. Look at ln ( Due south north ) , ln ( Southward n ) , and apply ln ( 1 + t ) t , ln ( one + t ) t , t > 0 . ) t > 0 . )

gatewoodtragivan.blogspot.com

Source: https://openstax.org/books/calculus-volume-2/pages/5-4-comparison-tests

0 Response to "How Do You Know When to Use the Limit Comparison Test"

Post a Comment

Iklan Atas Artikel

Iklan Tengah Artikel 1

Iklan Tengah Artikel 2

Iklan Bawah Artikel